On Building a Voice
|
On Building a Voice (2015) was commissioned by artist Lisa Skuret following conversations with theorist Zeynep Bulut (King’s College London) around the thinking and methods informing Skuret’s wider Arts Council-funded project Communal Materials; Or, Evolution Isn’t Fast Enough. A Call from the Library was one strand of this project, and Bulut wrote the essay in response to the work. In the essay, Bulut reflects on A Call from the Library as a process of building a voice together and, through the work, articulates a distinction between giving a voice and building a voice. The relations established through the project between bodies, sound, architecture, technology and place are central to that formulation. Bulut later acknowledged that A Call from the Library contributed to her conception of “building a voice” as distinct from “giving a voice”. A Call from the Library (2014) was a two-day durational performance installation incorporating live sound composition taking place throughout a former public library and community centre in London. Skuret approached the work as building a future library through the possibilities of listening and sound, with the proposition that “the building is the score.” The work was generated live by listening to and playing the library as a building, a concept, a utopian project and a space of knowledge production. Its score operated as a constellation of architecture, bodies, movement, gesture, algorithm, instructions, live text and sound. On Building a Voice was also presented by Bulut at Embodied Sound, a symposium curated by Guy Harries at the Centre for Performing Arts Development, University of East London, in 2015. Essay Extracts:On Building a Voice‘The building is the score’, writes Skuret. Following this cue, the installation draws attention to the act of building as a process of listening and playing with the space, with one another. That is, the building itself speaks with the participants, with a voice that is not necessarily known or given, a voice that allows us to question the limits of knowing in the first place. The nature of this voice comes into presence with the process of building a voice together. The implication here is that the activity of building and the voice that emerges from this activity are communal and exploratory, embodied and live. This voice is neither known nor pretending to know. More significantly, it can afford a state of not knowing.” “Agency of inanimate matters, life attitude of inorganic objects, and building both as an activity and as a site that is re-built are significantly relevant to A Call from the Library. In line with recent discussions on material agency – i.e. Jane Bennett’s Vibrant Matters and Rosi Braidotti’s The Posthuman – the proposal of the installation is to provide the conditions and structures for a shared agency, for neutral – that is neither idealized nor fully mastered or instrumentalized – ordinary and equal status between the building and the participants. The proposal can also be considered a communal experiment for exploring the shared agency between animate and inanimate matters. The equal status between voice and noise holds a potential key. The installation gives a way to a possibility of speech without intention, of building as a concrete process. Moving as they sang, Harris and Grant showed different registers, varied modes, positions and extensions of voice. Moving, they sang not simply to, but also with and through the parts of the building. Take the moment when Harris bent over the window, as he was singing; or Grant’s probe in the balcony with her voice, playing the surface of the balcony door, without necessarily pointing at anything. And again, consider Skuret’s live writing and movement in the space, and Ayyaz’s AAdM, which amplify and listen the space, and generate responses. The multisensory and multimodal network of these elements underlines the difference that I wish to make here: giving a voice, and building a voice. Giving a voice, as mentioned earlier, presumes a sense of agency over and intention toward the external object; whereas building a voice unfolds a process of un-doing this presumption, and thus encourages us to look at the reciprocity between the two. In that respect, building a voice necessitates imagining the voice as a multisensory interface, as distributed and shared. The building speaks with us, as we speak with it. The building embodies us, as we embody it. The call in A Call from the Library, I suggest, is then ethical. It contests the questionable limits of knowing and giving a voice, and in effect, allows us to embody an emerging voice, that we do not know.” – Zeynep Bulut Abstract: ‘On Building a Voice’ at Embodied Sound symposium:Zeynep Bulut On Building a Voice A Call from the Library (2014), a site-specific live installation, which took place in the former Rose Lipman Library, evokes questions on the possibility of building a voice. Based on a collaboration between artist Lisa Skuret and sound artist Seth Ayyaz and joined by performers Guy Harries and Kay Grant, the project takes its cue from “field-writing,” a concept and method that Skuret explores not simply in terms of writing a text, but also in terms of writing sound, voice, movement and place as text. The sound system of the installation corresponds to this idea. Ayyaz develops an “audio-adaptive machine,” which, as he describes, uses machine listening techniques to compare sound events between two microphones and generate real time responses to those events. The audio adaptive machine equilibrates and fractionalises the room sound as it interacts with the sounds activated, amplified and spatialized across eight loud speakers. Skuret’s live writing, Harries and Grants’ vocals, and the invitation both for the performers and for the audience to move across the space contribute to this aural architecture. Skuret provides textual material, and Harries and Grant move around and sing with different parts of the building using nonverbal vocals, objects, and short excerpts from Skuret’s live writing. All participants play different corners, surfaces, and matters of the building. “The building is the score,” writes Skuret. The installation thus re-forms the architecture as ecology, the act of building as a process of listening and playing with the place and with one another. In this process of building, the building itself speaks with the participants, with a voice that is not necessarily known or given, a voice that allows us to question the limits of knowing in the first place. This talk will discuss the nature of this voice, along with the process of building a voice, as suggested in A Call from the Library, as emergent, embodied and live. Audio Documentation of presentation: ‘On Building a Voice’ at Embodied Sound symposium:On Building a Voice Dr. Zeynep Bulut, King’s College London (2015) After hearing the call in A Call from the Library, I asked whether we could treat library as a place for un-knowing, or more so, not-knowing. We consider library a place for knowledge. Libraries are indeed the places where “knowledge” is collected, arranged, ordered, systematized, valued and validated. In a library, however, one rather gets lost, in every possible sense, physically, mentally and even emotionally. Imagine your first time – even your second or third time – in a library, walking around the book shelves, going up and down, trying to figure out the location of series, rambling in the matrix of alpha and numeric characters. Consider how one searches a book, that is how one comes across the wonders of a book without being reduced to the information in the book, or how one is asked to be silent as he moves, listens to another and talks to himself. Access to knowledge is a spatial practice. The more one walks and wonders in and around the library, the more s/he becomes humble in his/her presumption on the limits of knowing. How does one bear not knowing? How does one engage in an open process – be it a state of uncertainty, instability or precariousness—especially in times when control of and for knowledge is more heightened? A site-specific live installation, A Call from the Library evokes these questions in its aural architecture.i The installation, a collaboration between visual artist Lisa Skuret and sound artist Seth Ayyaz, and joined by performers Guy Harries and Kay Grant, is involved in Skuret’s larger project, Communal Materials; Or, Evolution Isn’t Fast Enough, which takes its inspiration from the idea of “deaccession.” The term, “deaccession,” indicates the removal of an item from a library, museum or an art gallery, to create allowance for new items. In response to this idea, the installation contests the “questionable value” of the places that we do not attend, the sounds or voices that we pass by but do not hear, the stories that we do not necessarily write or tell. In particular, the installation challenges the nature and experience of questionable matters in the way it engages with the former library, Rose Lipman Building. A part of a housing estate in Hackney, Rose Lipman Building was built to serve as a library and community centre. However, involved in an area of regeneration, the building has been recently withdrawn from this purpose. Skuret and Ayyaz consider the disposal of this initial purpose, and revisit the building through their practices of field writing and field recording. Field writing is a concept and method that Skuret probes not simply in terms of writing a text, but also in terms of writing sound, voice, movement and place as text. It thus allows a multimodal exploration of the site, through which unexpected encounters, be they a sound, an unnoticed aspect of the space, a move, or simply a moment of inspiration, become present. Skuret’s field writing is process based and live. Throughout the performance, she interacted with the participants as she wrote in and through the space. Ayyaz’s field recording can be considered a similar practice. The sound system that he built for the installation created an open network for listening. Ayyaz developed AAdM (audio-adaptive machine), which, as he describes, uses machine listening techniques to compare sound events between two microphones and generate real time responses to those events. The AAdM listened to all of the spaces in the building, and equilibrated and fractionalised the room sound as it interacted with the sounds activated, amplified and spatialized across eight loud speakers. As such, the system provided – and itself became— an emergent and interactive environment, in which both the audience and the participants of the project were encouraged to move in the space. Skuret’s live writing, Harries and Grants’ vocals, and the invitation both for the performers and for the audience to move in the space contributed to this aural architecture. More significantly, they together enabled us to experience the architecture not simply vertically, but also horizontally, in the form of an open environment. Skuret provided textual material, and Harries and Grant moved around and sang with different parts of the building using nonverbal vocals, objects, and short excerpts from Skuret’s live writing. Singing, or to be more specific, vocalization became a more explicitly articulated embodied practice here. It directly took its cue from the physical aspects of the building. As they were singing, Harris and Grant walked across different rooms, sat at the corners, played different parts – i.e. stairs, balcony, corners, doors, carpet etc. – of the building, and sang to and with them. The use of the objects and electronics mediated, sometimes punctuated the vocalizations. Long notes, re-coined words, word-like sounds, and mouth noises informed and were informed by the sounds activated across the space, as well as the physical distance between the spaces, objects, and the participants. Shape, color, amplitude, force, texture, and duration of the vocalizations took their forms in relation and in response to this multisensory network. Positioning themselves at different spots and moving around, Harris and Grant probed singing as a practice for navigating a space, for interacting with a physical surrounding. In doing so, they also gestured the voice as a multimodal interface, which could be distributed to a physical environment. As distributed, the voice appeared in different forms and shapes, which coincided with the sounds of inanimate matters and made them present and vocal as well. This practice also exposed us to forms of voicing and temporality of sounding. By voicing, I mean articulating the minor and micro, focused and (de) compressed moments and gestures of an utterance. Sounding, here, more directly indicates a case of resonance, of a multitude of both similarity and difference. All performers – field writers in Skuret’s terms – participate in this temporality of voicing and sounding. They play different edges, surfaces, and matters of the building. They engage with the unnoticed aspects and moments. “The building is the score,” writes Skuret. Following this cue, the installation draws attention to the act of building as a process of listening and playing with the space, with one another. That is, the building itself speaks with the participants, with a voice that is not necessarily known or given, a voice that allows us to question the limits of knowing in the first place. The nature of this voice comes into presence with the process of building a voice together. The implication here is that the activity of building and the voice that emerges from this activity are communal and exploratory, embodied and live. This voice is neither known nor pretending to know. More significantly, it can afford a state of not knowing. I wish to explore the nature of this voice by expanding on the questions of how a nonhuman body speaks with a voice, and how such voice can have a capacity for enduring a state of not knowing. These questions are no doubt informed by readings in posthumanism, process philosophy and history of media and technology. Take the history of phonograph. Kempelen, Maelzel, and Mical’s first automata, Willis’s synthetic vowel production, and Edouard Leon Scott’s phonautograph fed into Edison’s phonograph, as Friedrich Kittler tells. “A telegraph as an artificial mouth, a telephone as an artificial ear – the stage was set for the phonograph. Functions of the central nervous system had been technologically implemented,” he writes.ii The invention of machine speech – and giving a voice to an inanimate body – has direct relevance to history of avant-garde and experimental music. The most immediate example would be Russolo’s noise instruments and Futurists’ treatment of language, that is destruction of the totality and syntax of verbal language. Russolo’s noise instruments enabled vocalizing nonverbal noises such as humming, coughing, cracking etc. The resonance between voice and noise both derives from and further feeds into the sounds of an external environment. In the context of Futurism, the affinity between voice and noise was mostly due to the horror of the industrial soundscape. However, how noise overwhelms the voice, and vice versa, is significant for revisiting the limits of voice as constituted in its aurality. Alvin Lucier, John Cage, Robert Ashley, and Pauline Oliveros are some of the prominent composers who responded to this issue. In his discussion on voicing noise, Steven Connor refers to a similar trajectory of the avant-garde, yet warns us about the assimilation of noise into voice. As he argues, “the avant-garde, from Luigi Russolo to John Cage, resolved to listen to the voice of things; but in giving things a voice, they unwittingly assimilated aural alterity to the economy of human utterance.”iii The process of exploring voice in noise, and vice versa, may restore sounds of both human and nonhuman bodies into one another. But does this necessarily mean the “assimilation of aural alterity”? Does noise operate, as the human voice’s other? If assimilated, do voice and noise become really one? Does the human voice always precede or dominate the noise so that it could assimilate its other? I consider Connor’s remark useful and productive to propose and further these questions. They demand reflecting on the plasticity of voice and noise, what the economy of human utterance implies or could be, and whether noise and voice could acquire an equal status in the order of hearing and speech. These aspects more importantly underline the very first question asked above: how a nonhuman body could speak. Aura Satz and Jon Woods ask this question in the book, Articulate objects: Voice, Sculpture, and Performance.iv Looking at ventriloquism and the figure of marionette, they contest the capacity of a nonhuman body for “voice, speech and expression.” By articulate objects, they also “indicate the jointed segmentation of the body: the body built in parts in order for it to be moved and animated.”v The tension between the puppet associated with a voice and persona and the object fragmented into animated parts challenge the totality of a voice as limited to human body, and also the connection between speech and intention. Following Husserl, Derrida discussed intentionality as a necessary condition for speech. But can speech be present without an object of intention? Do we always speak ‘to or at’ someone? Intention also implies self-consciousness. One speaks to someone knowing that s/he is speaking. Drawing attention to the commonly perceived difference between phonograph and the human body, for instance, Friedrich Kittler posits: the phonograph does not have consciousness, it stores and plays, yet does not know that it plays.vi How does a building speak, and how does it know that it speaks? As the early 20th century art and architecture history tells us, the imagery of building – its monumental figure, portals, entries and exists – has direct connotations with the unconscious, thus with the psychoanalytic reading of the animation and abstraction of external objects. Sypros Papapetros’s book, On the Animation of the Inorganic: Art, Architecture, and the Extension of Life, critically and creatively responds to histories behind the life attitudes of objects. Papapetros first draws on the horror of industrial artifacts and external world for modern subjects. Departing from Wilhelm Worringer’s dissertation, Empathy and Abstraction (1907), he discusses how the frustration with modern life led to an “over investment of psychic power” into external objects: […] threatened modernist ego feel compelled to fetishistically displace upon inanimate objects. On the other hand, by constantly investing objects with psychic powers, modern subjects gradually renounce their own subjectivity. As in the wakening of the infantile sexuality the issue of agency becomes mysterious and inexplicable: “Things are happening to us, and we don’t where they’re coming from!” …. Such is the ‘landscape effect’ of animation created by leveling the verticality of the human subject onto the horizontal plane of material effects – a thick tapestry of intertwined associations with no essential distinction between points of action and forces of motivation behind an event. The animation of the inorganic promoted by Worringer is then essentially an act of transgression; it heralds the infusion of life in a domain to which the animate did not formerly belong.vii The over investment in the objects result either in “mastery” or “mutual exclusion,” as Papapetros argues.viii The exhaustion of the subjecthood and objects — the impossibility of fully accessing or mastering either of these categories — never leads to a resolution. That is, the external objects remain idealized and desired while affirming pathos and lack as life drive. This state of the object, as Papapetros argues, the failure to approach the tension between the human beings and the external objects as neutral, as ordinary, rather than destroyed or idealized, gives a way to the later theories on empathy and anthropomorphism. Papapetros’s argument is worthwhile here to consider both to historicize the readings on building as a monumental and yet impossible figure in art history and psychoanalysis, and also to further building within the context of the agency of external objects. Agency of inanimate matters, life attitude of inorganic objects, and building both as an activity and as a site that is re-built are significantly relevant to A Call from the Library. In line with recent discussions on material agency – i.e. Jane Bennett’s Vibrant Matters and Rosi Braidotti’s The Posthuman – the proposal of the installation is to provide the conditions and structures for a shared agency, for neutral – that is neither idealized nor fully mastered or instrumentalized – ordinary and equal status between the building and the participants.ix The proposal can also be considered a communal experiment for exploring the shared agency between animate and inanimate matters. The equal status between voice and noise holds a potential key. The installation gives a way to a possibility of speech without intention, of building as a concrete process. Moving as they sang, Harris and Grant showed different registers, varied modes, positions and extensions of voice. Moving, they sang not simply to, but also with and through the parts of the building. Take the moment when Harris bent over the window, as he was singing; or Grant’s probe in the balcony with her voice, playing the surface of the balcony door, without necessarily pointing at anything. And again, consider Skuret’s live writing and movement in the space, and Ayyaz’s AAdM, which amplify and listen the space, and generate responses. The multisensory and multimodal network of these elements underlines the difference that I wish to make here: giving a voice, and building a voice. Giving a voice, as mentioned earlier, presumes a sense of agency over and intention toward the external object; whereas building a voice unfolds a process of un-doing this presumption, and thus encourages us to look at the reciprocity between the two. In that respect, building a voice necessitates imagining the voice as a multisensory interface, as distributed and shared. The building speaks with us, as we speak with it. The building embodies us, as we embody it. The call in A Call from the Library, I suggest, is then ethical. It contests the questionable limits of knowing and giving a voice, and in effect, allows us to embody an emerging voice, that we do not know. Building a voice that we do not know, we attend to the experience of “questionable matters” as matters that count, the question of what makes these matters questionable in the first place, and the ways in which we tend to re-cycle, re-store or change them. The experience of the questionable, the question on the questionable, and the tendency to recycle are indeed entangled. That is, they all co-operate and present themselves as an affair. Looking into this affair, one might consider how we reassemble the sounds that we encounter in the installation. We re-assemble the sounds of the space along with the voices. The voices are mediated and amplified by the space, as well as by the participants and audience, and the instruments and objects that Grant and Harris use. However, the voices also take part in forming and echoing the concrete sounds that one more directly identifies with the physical space itself, such as the sound of the balcony door, floor, stage, and stairs. AAdM, as described earlier, generates the network of feedback and response between these sounds. In this network, sounds are not simply reciprocated but also diffracted. It is possible to capture a similarity between a non-vocal sound and a vocal sound; yet the complexity of where one hears, how one listens and to what extent the sounds mingle does not allow a direct correspondence. The question on how one identifies the voices, that is the ways in which the building speaks, remains. Considering the self-generative process of the sound system here – and the history and location of Rose Lipman Building – one could be reminded of re-cycle, re-generation and transformation. However, despite the feedback and response, neither the environment of AAdM nor its participants re-cycle or transform the sounds into one another. We hear the sounds both individually and in relation to one another. The environment here makes us more responsive to the event of sound, to the production of a voice within this event, and the encounter between the two. At times of precariousness and temporal engagements, encounter is the word. Take it as noun or verb. What I mean here is both. Building a voice that we do not know, encounter comes to surface. It energizes us to afford something, but how do we afford not knowing? How could voice, which is neither known nor pretending to know, afford a state of not knowing? I do not intend to answer this question here. But within the context of the installation, one could say: If one is in it, s/he can bare its openness. The emergent voice here enables us to be in movement, in the activity of encounter. I begin with the wonder in library; I wish to conclude with the ethics of wondering. In her text, “Wondering the World Directly,” philosopher, visual artist and dancer Erin Manning discusses the directionality of encounter, the significance of wonder, of movement, and how “movement outruns the subject.”x Manning articulates movement itself as wonder, as a “force of relational attunement.”xi Drawing on the possible connections between Merleau Ponty’s phenomenology and Alfred North Whitehead’s process philosophy, she stresses a movement, one that goes “beyond me and mine,”xii one that articulates “body” not in the form of noun, but in the form of verb, action. To consider body as verb – bodying in Manning’s words –mobilizes the limits of building both as noun and as verb. “What we know are edgings and contourings, forces and intensities: a body is its movement… A philosophy of the body never begins with the body: it bodies,” Manning writes.xiii This proposition is telling for what A Call from the Library “bodies” loudly: sounds of the corners, edges and surfaces, and the building of a voice, which speaks as it wonders. – Dr. Zeynep Bulut, King’s College London (2015) NOTES i I use the word “aural architecture” as it relates to spatial awareness. Following Barry Blesser’s and Linda-Ruth Salter’s account, I wish to indicate the “social behavior” of a space. See Barry Blesser and Linda Ruth Salter, Spaces Speak, Are You Listening, (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2009). ii Friedrich A. Kittler, Gramophone, Film, Typewriter, trans. Geoffrey Winthrop-Young and Michael Wutz, (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1999), pp. 27-28. iii Steven Connor, “The Decomposing Voice of Postmodern Music,” New Literary History, Vol. 32, No. 3, Voice and Human Experience (Summer, 2001), pp. 472. iv Aura Satz and Jon Woods (eds.), Articulate Objects: Voice, Sculpture and Performance, (Oxford, Bern: Peter Lang, 2009). v Ibid. 15. vi Kittler evokes this point in his discussion on Jean-Marie Guyau, memory and phonograph. Aligned with the capacity for storing, Kittle asks whether the phonograph has self-consciousness, whether it does “remember” and “hear” what it plays. See Kittler, 30-33. vii Spyros Papapetros, On the Animation of the Inorganic: Art, Architecture and the Extension of Life, (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 2012), p. viii. viii Ibid. ix. ix See Jane Bennett, Vibrant Matters: A Political Ecology of Things, (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2010) and Rosi Braidotti, The Posthuman, (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2013). x Manning here explains how movement itself becomes a kind of wonder: “From noun to verb, what movement does is make apparent that nothing is quite what it seems. That nothing is quite what it seems suggests a kind of wonder.” See Erin Manning, “Wondering the World Directly, or, How Movement Outruns the Subject,” Body and Society, Special Issue: Rhythm, Movement, Embodiment 2014, Vol. 20 (3&4) p. 165. xi Ibid. 163. xii By “beyond me and mine,” Manning indicates “leaving I behind,” and in effect acknowledging the movement as subject within in the process of moving. As she argues, this state leads to “wondering the world directly.” Ibid. 165-66. xiii Ibid. 162-3. |






















